The Toronto Blue Jays had a game to forget on Tuesday, losing to the Boston Red Sox, 10–2. But while the result was forgettable, the Blue Jays still delivered one play that fans will remember for quite some time.

The Toronto Blue Jays outfielder fell down tracking the ball but still managed to find it mid-recovery for a miraculous catch in his season debut.

Boston hit five homers through three innings for the first time since Sept. 8, 2009, when Dustin Pedroia led a five-homer barrage against the Orioles.